Skip to main content

Catholics and the Origins of Halloween

I get so tired of social media around Halloween. 
“Halloween is witches/pagans/satanists high holiday!”
“It’s an evil day!”
“Christians have no business celebrating Halloween!”

As a Catholic Christian mom whose main goal in life is to teach my children to know, love, and serve God, I’m here to remind y’all that HALLOWEEN IS A CHRISTIAN HOLIDAY. And I’m not about to let our Hallowtide be hijacked! 

(Y’all before your All Saints party in 2015–St. Nicholas, St. Maria Goretti, St. Teresa of Calcutta, St. Jude, St. Agnes, and St. Vincent DePaul.)

The word "hallow" means holy, consecrated. Halloween is a shortened form of All Hallows' Eve, the vigil before All Hallows' (Saints) Day on November 1.  All Souls' Day is on November 2. These three days are referred to as Hallowtide, and we celebrate the Communion of Saints.

All Saints’ Day is a holy day of obligation, which means it’s important, there will be a special Mass, and we are expected to attend it! We commemorate the martyrs and saints in heaven, heroes of our faith. 
On All Souls, we pray for the souls of our faithful departed loved ones in purgatory, a practice which has been a part of true Christianity from the beginning. We have archeological and written evidence of this, and it’s in the Bible, just not the Protestant Bibles, because Martin Luther 1500 years later tossed out books that didn’t fit his personal beliefs. (More about purgatory, the Bible, and the Reformation coming later.)
It’s not an obligation to attend the All Souls services, rosaries, and the blessing of graves at our cemeteries, but if we can, we should. One of these days, it will be us benefitting from the prayers. 

Social media is full of posts about Halloween being influenced by an ancient festival of Samhain, the "god of death.” Some claim November 1st was the Celtic new year, that the Celts believed the veil between the spirit world was very thin the night before, and that spirits roamed the earth on this night. Many claim the Catholic Church later started celebrating martyrs and souls in purgatory to coincide with what the local people were doing. 

The thing is, none of these ideas are supported by any sort of historical or archeological evidence. They can be traced to bad scholarship from the 19th century. They are myths, widely circulated and repeated without questioning. That might have been somewhat understandable back in the days of finding information through visiting libraries, using the Dewey decimal system, and flipping through pages in books. But we no longer live in that world. We can find the information we are looking through in minutes. 

When I finally got around to trying to learn more about this ancient "god of death", I found out that Samhain is Gaelic and literally means “summer’s end.” It wasn’t the new year. The Gaelic culture did not have a “god of death.” Samhain was not connected to anything religious or anything to do with death or spirits, but simply a harvest party on one island (Ireland.)

The only actual evidence connecting November 1st (and the vigil, October 31st) to a commemoration of the dead comes from Catholic Christianity, the only brand of Christianity that existed back then.

Joe Heschmeyer at Catholic Answers does a good job of examining the historical records we have. Start by taking a few minutes to go watch/listen to Is Halloween a Pagan Holiday? Then ask questions and look stuff up. 

The belief in the communion of saints is part of the oldest Christian creed. The anniversary of a martyr’s death was called their “birthday" (now called "feast day"), their tombs were decorated, altars were built over tombs, and Christians gathered there to offer prayers. In the early centuries of Christianity, especially under Roman emperor Diocletian (284-305 AD), there were more and more martyrs, so many that it became increasingly hard to honor each one on their own anniversary. It became more feasible to celebrate a common feast day. Celebrations of the martyrs were held in various churches by the 4th century. 
On May 13, 615 AD the first church-wide celebration was held, known as the "Feast of All Martyrs." It later expanded to include honoring all the saints, and it was moved to November 1st in 844 AD. It came to be known as All Hallows' Day, with the vigil, All Hallows' Eve, shortened to Hallowe'en. 

November is near the end of our liturgical year, with the new liturgical year beginning at Advent, when we prepare to celebrate the Nativity of Our Lord. The end of the liturgical year, along with the shortening hours of light, longer hours of darkness, the end of harvest, and leaves falling from trees is a natural time for humans to be thinking about the end of life. This date just makes sense. 

It’s probable that other cultures were also thinking about death and the afterlife as harvest ended and winter approached. It doesn’t mean Catholics “borrowed” anything from them. God reveals Himself and His truth to us through His creation. The evidence seems to point to other cultures adopting our ideas, not the other way around. 

Maybe some of the traditions around this day sprang up out of superstition. Humans have always feared death. Others, like jack o’lanterns, came from fictional stories. Trick-or-treating more likely came from the Christian celebration, the practice of baking sweets (soul cakes) to prepare for the holy day and the poor going door-to-door asking for sweets or alms in exchange for prayers. 

The fact that there is so much confusion, darkness, and evil activity surrounding this time underscores the importance of the truths we are celebrating. Knowing how the enemy works, an increase in demonic activity means there is something in our celebration that the enemy hates and fears. Nothing in satanism is a unique idea; everything is an inversion, perversion, desecration or mocking of everything holy.
Have you ever seen a satanic black mass, maybe in a book or documentary? It inverts the Catholic Mass. They say our Mass prayers backward. They attempt to steal things like our crucifixes, vessels, our priest’s garments, and our holy water, to desecrate. They especially go after our consecrated hosts. Let that sink in a minute. We aren't the only ones who believe the Eucharist is Real Presence of Jesus. (James 2:19.) 

The way we Catholics combat evil and triumph over darkness is by doing what we’ve been doing for a millennia—worship, prayer, fasting, and almsgiving. I hope y'all will teach your own kids about the saints, the way they triumphed over death, the miracles they performed in Jesus’ name while on earth, and the miracles we receive by their intercession even after their death.

Whatever festivities we decide to take part in, if we put God first, keep this holy day of obligation, and keep the fun in its proper context, we have no worries. Saint parties are fun. But we can also go to fall festivals and secular parties. Dressing up is fun! We stay away from evil decorations and costumes, but we don’t shy away from symbols of death, skulls, skeletons, graveyards. We have nothing to fear about death. Death is how we get to see Jesus face-to-face.

 "For this corruptible must put on incorruption; and this mortal must put on immortality. And when this mortal hath put on immortality, then shall come to pass the saying that is written: Death is swallowed up in victory. 
O death, where is thy victory? O death, where is thy sting?" 
1 Corinthians 15:53-55

“Precious in the sight of the Lord is the death of His saints.”
Psalm 116:15

I may edit posts for clarity, to add thoughts or add links.
Updated 11-4-26



Comments

Popular Posts

Why Do Catholics Pray to Mary and the Saints?

I was nondenominational when I first met cradle-Catholic Greg. One of the first things I wanted to know was who do Catholics worship? I saw them wearing crucifixes, I knew they had Bibles and said the Lord’s Prayer, but they also had statues of Mary and a bunch of other people they prayed to. It confused me. “You say you believe in the Bible. But why do you pray to and worship Mary and the saints? That goes against the Bible." Catholics DON’T worship saints, Mary, or any other creature. We honor them, but we only worship God.  “Well, why do you pray to them then?” What we actually do is ask for intercession from the Church in heaven, in God’s presence, the same as we would ask intercession from the Church on earth.  The reason we ask the saints to intercede, to pray for us, can be summed up in two sentences:  1. We believe ”The prayer of a righteous man has great power in its effects.” ( James 5:16 ) 2. And we believe in the Communion of Saints. The Church is Christ’s bod...

Different Forms of Prayer

 Prayer is communication with God, who is a real, divine Person.  I know that some people believe God is not real, and I believe it's because they haven't met Him and don't know Him. For those of us who do know Him and have felt His presence and love, nobody can convince us He's imaginary, any more than they could convince us that any other person we know that they haven't met is imaginary. People who have encountered God's love are willing to give up their lives rather than deny Him. And that peace and love we feel in His Presence is why we want to share Him with others. Catholics believe that there is no one-size-fits-all when it comes to praying.  We have five main forms of prayer, or communication with our Loved One . 1. Blessing or Adoration is when we acknowledge God as our Creator and give Him all glory and honor. 2. Petition is where we ask Him for our needs and desires. 3. Intercession is where we ask God for things on behalf of others. When we ...

How to Pray a Rosary

If you are new to praying the rosary, it may be helpful to follow along with an app , video or podcast. A search on platforms like YouTube, Spotify, or Apple will yield numerous results! Listen to a couple; you may find you prefer a certain voice or background music over the others. How to Pray a Rosary 1. Hold the crucifix and make the Sign of the cross. “In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit.” 2. Still holding the crucifix, say the Apostles' Creed. “I believe in God, the Father almighty, creator of heaven and earth, and in Jesus Christ, his only Son, our Lord, who was conceived by the Holy Spirit, born of the Virgin Mary, suffered under Pontius Pilate, was crucified, died and was buried; he descended into hell; on the third day he rose again from the dead, he ascended into heaven, and is seated at the right hand of God the Father almighty; from there he will come to judge the living and the dead. I believe in the Holy Spirit, the holy catholic Church...