(Me and Greg, Easter 2002)
I have early memories of my childhood, as early as my second birthday. I can remember feeling at a very young age that even when I was alone, someone else was with me. It was a comforting presence. Later, I learned that God was the presence I felt. I learned that God exists in three persons: Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. God the Father sent His Son to earth as a man, Jesus, to show us the way to heaven. When He returned to heaven, He sent the Holy Spirit to guide us.
I said a prayer asking Jesus to come into my heart to make it “official” at an old-fashioned revival the summer I was eight years old. A few weeks later, I was baptized in my own Baptist church. (1981, I think? The church burned later and my baptismal record along with it.) The importance of baptism, I had been taught, was that it was symbolic of death and resurrection, a public profession of faith, and an act of obedience. Afterward, I stood up front, and the congregation sang a joyful hymn and processed down the aisle to shake my hand, hug my neck and welcome me into the Church. I was presented with my very own "adult" King James Version Bible, which I read because I was a voracious reader even in second grade. (My first grade teacher, Mrs. Buck, kept giving me more advanced books to read until I was reading from sixth grade books. She also let me read from the Bible she kept in her desk.)
But my childhood was turbulent.
My mom had an intellectual disability, along with other psychiatric issues. Back in the 80s, “mentally retarded” was the term used. She said she didn’t finish high school because she was bullied, and I witnessed people calling her names and talking bad about her behind her back. We walked around town together because she often didn’t have a car, and sometimes people yelled things like "retard" or "fat ass" as they drove by. More polite people suddenly spoke in hushed voices when we were around, and even the good church folk whispered. None of it escaped my notice.
My Dad also had challenges. He also saw psychiatrists and was diagnosed with bipolar disorder. He made several suicide attempts by overdosing on his medications during my childhood and teen years. But most people could see he had a kind heart, and I thought he tried his best to follow Jesus. I loved him very much.
He and my mom lived together and moved out and divorced and remarried each other so many times I lost count (five divorces maybe?) My mom went on to marry and divorce and live with several other men. My Dad married my stepmom twice, and then they lived together for more than 20 years until he died. She brought him some stability.
When my parents separated, my dad always took my brother with him, but sometimes he left me with my mom, and I felt abandoned. We frequently moved from one broken down rent house, trailer park, or apartment to another. We got food stamps, but when those quickly ran out, we ate beans and potatoes for weeks. My mom mostly slept or watched tv, and I spent a lot of time alone. I preferred that to when she was awake and screaming hateful things at me. Our house was always embarrassingly filthy. Sometimes our utilities were shut off. My clothes were worn donations and usually dirty. Nobody helped me wash my naturally curly hair or brush my teeth. Rather than deal with my tangled curls (and frequent head lice) the adults in my life cut my hair very short. I was teased and bullied a lot at school. People gossiped about the sketchy men that hung around, but nobody seemed to really care about whether I was safe or not. Social workers showed up a couple times over the years, but nothing ever happened.
I felt like I didn’t belong anywhere, not in my extended family, not at school, not at church. I heard said within my earshot, on many occasions, some variation of “that poor girl ain't gonna amount to a hill of beans.”
And I questioned the One who made me, the One whose presence I could still feel—“I thought you loved me? Why do you let all this happen to me?”
I was almost 12 years old when I returned home from school one day to find my mom had left, for good that time. A few months later, my dad remarried my stepmom. By then, I had learned to take care of myself. I was in advanced classes at school, and I made mostly A’s. I started playing clarinet in the band, and I made friends. I even eventually made the All-State band in high school and earned music and academic scholarships that completely paid for attending the college of my choice.
But in seventh grade, I began having nightmares, the kind that caused me to run screaming out the front door. Those nightmares continued throughout my teen and young adult years.
By the time I was a teen, I was tired of feeling unwanted, and I grew rebellious. For a time, I turned away from God. I lived with my great-grandma in high school, then I moved in with my older police officer boyfriend my senior year. We got married a week before I turned 18, had a baby together a couple years later, and divorced after five years. I chose to try to make it on my own rather than tolerate unfaithfulness and physical abuse.
I was in the middle of nursing school when we divorced, and nursing school--on top of trying to work enough hospital shifts as a nurse aid, while trying to spend enough time with my toddler--was brutal. I was bound and determined to finish because I wanted Adrien to have a better life than I did. After graduation, I began working as a Registered Nurse on the cardiac telemetry floor. I bought my own house, and I thought I would finally find some peace living on my own. I lived my life the way I wanted, rules be damned!
But doing “whatever makes you happy” did not make me truly happy, nor did it bring me peace, nor fill the emptiness inside me. By the time I realized that and looked back to God, there He was, quietly waiting.
I questioned everything...why did I believe God was real and not a figment of my imagination? How did I know Jesus was really who the Apostles said He was? How did I know He really rose from the dead? I did what I always did when I had questions…I read books.
I was 24 years old when I decided I would follow Jesus, for real, no turning back. I didn't just have myself to think of anymore; I wanted Adrien to know Jesus. I began praying on my way to and from work, and I bought a new Bible, taking my time to research different translations. I attended different churches looking for one to attend regularly. I settled on a non-denominational church.
At work, I was precepted by an older Christian nurse my first 12 weeks on the job. I loved Ann Thomas. She was loving, and she was also tough. We had many discussions about the Bible at the nurses’ station at 2am. She encouraged my interest in a cute Respiratory Therapist, Greg, who seemed different from any other guy I had met. “Greg is such a nice young man,” she would say. “He’s a Christian, you know.”
At work, I was precepted by an older Christian nurse my first 12 weeks on the job. I loved Ann Thomas. She was loving, and she was also tough. We had many discussions about the Bible at the nurses’ station at 2am. She encouraged my interest in a cute Respiratory Therapist, Greg, who seemed different from any other guy I had met. “Greg is such a nice young man,” she would say. “He’s a Christian, you know.”
(A picture of Ann at our wedding reception. She’s the one who crocheted all those snowflakes I put on our tree every Christmas.)
I noticed Greg brought his Bible to work some nights.
And then I noticed he also brought the Catechism of the Catholic Church some nights.
Wait, a Catholic? I had not known many growing up. My fourth grade teacher was Catholic; she wore a crucifix and led us in the Lord’s Prayer every morning. Many of my college sorority sisters were Catholic, and I attended Mass with them a couple times. I knew they believed in Jesus, but they had other strange beliefs and practices. What they said confused me, and nobody could answer my questions satisfactorily.
Wait, a Catholic? I had not known many growing up. My fourth grade teacher was Catholic; she wore a crucifix and led us in the Lord’s Prayer every morning. Many of my college sorority sisters were Catholic, and I attended Mass with them a couple times. I knew they believed in Jesus, but they had other strange beliefs and practices. What they said confused me, and nobody could answer my questions satisfactorily.
But Greg was endearing, and I enjoyed his quirky sense of humor. We began spending a lot of time together, although I had no intention of getting seriously involved with him.
Our conversations about our beliefs began when he offered to help me paint and wallpaper my house. As we worked, I asked him the usual questions. As I had suspected, Greg stumbled over answering my questions about his faith, and I had the hope of "converting" him.
I was a member of Calvary Chapel (nondenominational) by this time and was serious about studying my Bible. I had bought a Strong’s Concordance so I could dig deeper into what it all meant. I read about the Catholic Church from tracts that were displayed at Calvary Chapel services, and I tried to share what I read with Greg, that the Church he belonged to was a false church.
In the meantime, Greg began searching the internet (this was 1998), and buying Catholic books, audiotapes, and videotapes. He stubbornly believed that he was a member of the Church Jesus founded, and if he didn’t know the answers to my questions, he was going to find them!
When Greg shared with me what he learned from his Catholic books and tapes and articles, it only made me angry. I just knew that this stuff couldn't be true. I believed the Bible was all I needed to support what I believed. Yet, with only the Bible, I couldn't come up with satisfactory rebuttals to the Catholic arguments, which heavily referenced Scripture. They also referenced other Christian writings from early centuries. I could only present what I believed the Bible said. For some people, a subjective, emotional argument—what I feel or believe — is compelling. But not for Greg. It dawned on me that if nobody has the authority to interpret Scripture for me, then logically, I also cannot interpret Scripture for them. I couldn’t tell Greg the Catholic interpretation is wrong…only I don't agree with it.
Greg left his books at my house, and I could not stop myself from opening them. I figured I should use Catholic sources so I could build a successful argument. Many objections I raised didn’t gain traction because they were based on misinformation. This was one of the first things that bothered me. Were those tracts I had read uninformed…or did they intentionally misrepresent Catholic beliefs so that they would be easier to “refute”? Since all the Catholic teachings are in writing and readily available, not presenting them accurately just weakens credibility.
Eventually, we came to a point in our relationship where we both felt we needed to get married or part ways. We couldn’t seem to let each other go, we both prayed about it, and we decided to begin marriage preparation. I honestly felt a little resentment having to jump through hoops to get my previous marriage annulled, so that this Church would allow us to get married! But when it was over, I surprisingly felt closure and peace. (The annulment was straightforward—my first marriage was to someone who had been previously married and divorced; that prevented it from being a valid sacrament.)
We agreed to disagree and live in peace, each striving to serve God in our own way…together.
I saw plenty examples of successful marriages where spouses had different beliefs. We were married in December 1999, at Greg’s church, with his priest and my pastor co-officiating. We settled down in my hometown, and I began attending the church where I was baptized as a child, even though I didn’t agree with everything they taught. I didn’t agree with everything in any denomination, but I read in my Bible that I should gather with other believers.
Greg attended Sunday school with me, then he walked over to the Catholic Mass a couple of blocks away, then I picked him up when my service ended. On special occasions, I attended Mass with him. We were both fairly comfortable with this arrangement.
Even so, I asked my Sunday school class to pray that Greg would leave the Catholic Church.
In the meantime…
While we were going through our marriage prep, we had to sit through a talk on NFP (Natural Family Planning.) As a RN, I believed that the Catholic Church's teaching on contraception was ignorant and outdated. I did not listen with an open mind (remind me to share my amusing story about that experience.) But the information presented was different from what I expected, and it got my attention. I learned NFP has a solid scientific foundation, and I reluctantly admitted it deserved further research, mainly because hormonal contraception had caused bad side effects for me.
I did start reading about NFP, and then why the Catholic Church opposes contraception. I was exposed for the first time to the moral issues involved in using contraception, then the Church's teaching on marriage, and I was touched by it. I had already seen the world's ideas about marriage, and I could see the churches I had attended were very much influenced by the world view. I didn't want that. I wanted this for my marriage.
I also felt uncomfortable by the lack of unity among Christians. All the Protestant/ evangelical/ fundamentalist denominations who claim the Bible alone as their authority on matters of faith and morals, also claim that the Bible is clear and can easily be interpreted by the individual with the help of the Holy Spirit. If that’s true, ALL of them should be able to easily and definitively say “this is how we spend eternity with Jesus” and everyone’s answers should agree. But that’s not how it works, is it? This one says faith alone. That one says faith and works. This one says it’s eternally secured. That one says we can fall away. This one says baptism is only a symbol, that one says baptism is necessary for salvation. Ok–when and how should it be done? This one says you have to receive the Holy Spirit and speak in tongues? That one says God predestined us before the world began?
While we were going through our marriage prep, we had to sit through a talk on NFP (Natural Family Planning.) As a RN, I believed that the Catholic Church's teaching on contraception was ignorant and outdated. I did not listen with an open mind (remind me to share my amusing story about that experience.) But the information presented was different from what I expected, and it got my attention. I learned NFP has a solid scientific foundation, and I reluctantly admitted it deserved further research, mainly because hormonal contraception had caused bad side effects for me.
I did start reading about NFP, and then why the Catholic Church opposes contraception. I was exposed for the first time to the moral issues involved in using contraception, then the Church's teaching on marriage, and I was touched by it. I had already seen the world's ideas about marriage, and I could see the churches I had attended were very much influenced by the world view. I didn't want that. I wanted this for my marriage.
I also felt uncomfortable by the lack of unity among Christians. All the Protestant/ evangelical/ fundamentalist denominations who claim the Bible alone as their authority on matters of faith and morals, also claim that the Bible is clear and can easily be interpreted by the individual with the help of the Holy Spirit. If that’s true, ALL of them should be able to easily and definitively say “this is how we spend eternity with Jesus” and everyone’s answers should agree. But that’s not how it works, is it? This one says faith alone. That one says faith and works. This one says it’s eternally secured. That one says we can fall away. This one says baptism is only a symbol, that one says baptism is necessary for salvation. Ok–when and how should it be done? This one says you have to receive the Holy Spirit and speak in tongues? That one says God predestined us before the world began?
They all have the Bible verses to “prove” their position.
All these contradicting beliefs cannot be true, so which one is the truth and which ones are false?
When talking with someone of another faith tradition, presenting Bible verses that contradict their doctrines quickly dissolves into circular reasoning. They’ll simply sidestep with “that’s not what that means.” Because it’s not what they believe. “Truth” is not actually “what does the Bible say?” Truth is “what do I believe the Bible says?”
A closer examination of this belief in the Bible alone as sole authority reveals that it’s not actually the Bible that has authority; it’s each individual’s personal beliefs. I am my own authority.
This results in dissension, thousands of factions, and massive confusion, which goes against the repeated admonitions in the Bible for believers to avoid dissension and factions and to remain united, remain ONE. The Bible calls this a work of the flesh, not a fruit of the Holy Spirit. And this disunity gives the non-believers ammunition to use against the Gospel message.
I figured if anyone could help us interpret the Bible correctly, it was the early Church Fathers—guys like Ignatius, Polycarp, Iraneus, Justin Martyr—who lived close to the time of the Apostles. Like the Apostles, they chose death over renouncing what they believed. They kept Christianity alive while the emperors worked to extinguish it.
I had always believed that the Church started off on the right track, teaching what Jesus and the Apostles taught, but then as the centuries progressed, the Church moved farther and farther from Biblical truth, inserting "tradition" in it's place. I had been taught that this apostasy began with the so-called conversion of Constantine and Christianity becoming the official religion of the Roman empire. After that, Christianity became "paganized" but an underground group of the faithful kept the true Biblical teaching alive until the errors were finally corrected during the Reformation.
But that’s not what I discovered when I read the Church Fathers’ writings for myself. Having been exposed to what Catholics believe…I recognized Catholic doctrine.
But that’s not what I discovered when I read the Church Fathers’ writings for myself. Having been exposed to what Catholics believe…I recognized Catholic doctrine.
The early Church was in agreement that the teaching of the Apostles and their successors (bishops) was authoritative, whether by word of mouth or by letter. Apostolic authority is found in the Bible and in the Christian writings immediately following the time of the apostles, before the writings were even canonized as Sacred Scripture. And it gave the Church a unity that caused the early church to be called “catholic” (Greek for “universal”) from the beginning. St. Ignatius, bishop of Antioch, a martyr and friend of St. John the Apostle, referred to the catholic Church in his Epistle to the Smyrnaeans on the way to his martyrdom around 107-110 AD. For reference, St. John wrote his gospel somewhere between 90-110 AD. (There’s a link to all the writings of the Church Fathers in the sidebar to the right.)
The Church Fathers left written evidence of what the “Catholic” Church believed and how they practiced a couple centuries before Constantine.
Where is the written evidence for the claim that the Church became paganized? What exactly changed? When? Where? By whom?
The early Church Fathers called the bread and wine the Eucharist, and they believed it is really the flesh and blood of Jesus. That belief flows smoothly from the Bible (John 6:53-58, Matthew 26:26-28, Mark 14:22-24, Luke 22:19-20 and 1 Corinthians 11:23-30) to St. Ignatius of Antioch and onward. Folks didn’t start saying it was symbolic until around 1500 years later.
It seemed to me that the doctrines of Martin Luther and the other so-called Reformers who split from him were the doctrines that diverged from orthodoxy. The more I read writings of the Reformers, the more my sinking feeling grew. “You will know them by their fruits.” The fruit of the Reformation-- the Body of Christ splintering into dozens of dissenting factions--is what the Bible calls a work of the flesh, not a fruit of the Holy Spirit.
I also had to confront where the Bible came from. For almost four centuries, the Church was without an official canon. I was taught that the canon was closed after the book of Revelation was written by John. But I could see…it didn’t just close itself.
When Christians gathered to celebrate the Eucharist, they read from the writings of the Old Testament (the Greek Septuagint, which contained the deuterocanon), gospel accounts, and epistles that had been copied and passed around. Writings such as the epistle of Clement, Barnabas, and the Didache (Teaching of the Twelve) were accepted as sacred by some in early centuries. The second epistle of Peter, Hebrews, James, 2 and 3 John, and Revelation were not accepted as sacred by a few.
As with the issue of circumcision in Acts 15, the Church leaders called meetings and came to an agreement. They didn’t say “do what the Holy Spirit leads you to do” and leave it up to individual congregations. An official universal canon of Sacred Scripture was decided upon. The list of books to include appeared at the Council of Rome in 382 AD, the Synod of Hippo in 393 AD, and the Councils of Carthage in 397 and 419 AD. They were reaffirmed later at the Council of Florence in 1431–1449 and once again reaffirmed at the Council of Trent in 1545-1563.
Nowhere in the Bible does Jesus tell his apostles to write stuff down, nor do He or the Apostles indicate which New Testament writings were The Word of God.
How do we know the Church—men—got it right?
We all believe by the guidance of the Holy Spirit, yes?
I was taught “Catholics added books to the Bible.” But all the lists of Sacred Scripture included the books of the deuterocanon, which Protestants call “the apocrypha.” They were The Word of God for more than 1500 years, until they were rejected by Martin Luther and his followers. They were still included in the 1611 King James Bible, and they were later omitted from Bibles in the 1800s.
I was taught “Catholics added books to the Bible.” But all the lists of Sacred Scripture included the books of the deuterocanon, which Protestants call “the apocrypha.” They were The Word of God for more than 1500 years, until they were rejected by Martin Luther and his followers. They were still included in the 1611 King James Bible, and they were later omitted from Bibles in the 1800s.
Sure, Catholics added them…at the same time they added all the rest of the New Testament writings. And Protestants removed them a millennia later because they contradicted novel Protestant teachings.
Did the Holy Spirit lead the existing Church when they decided and reaffirmed what belonged in the Holy Bible all those centuries?
Or did He leave His Church without guidance and allow the Holy Bible—His Word—to continue in error for 1500 years before sending Martin Luther to correct it? I could not honestly accept that. It didn’t line up with Jesus’ promises to not leave us as orphans or that the gates of hell would not prevail against His Church.
And how do we even know the Holy Bible is inerrant? Before the printing press was invented around 1440 AD, all
the manuscripts were painstakingly copied by the hands of Catholic priests and monks who worked as scribes. There are no surviving originals, only copies.
How can we trust that those copies that eventually made their way to the printing presses, to the Bible I now hold in my hand, contain no errors?
Again, by guidance and protection of the Holy Spirit, right?
Ok, so Holy Spirit guided the men in the Catholic Church to preserve The Word of God by hand for centuries without error.
The Holy Spirit guided the Catholic Church to gather to authoritatively define what books belonged in Word of God.
Maybe I should listen to the Catholic Church’s interpretation of what it means?
So now I looked more closely and openly at what I had done my best to argue around earlier. Where do the Catholic Church teachings come from? Why? When?
Catholic doctrine is not “unbiblical” as so many “Bible only” Christians claim; it fits together and makes more sense than the myriads of disjointed contradicting Protestant doctrines.
It was my own private personal interpretation of the Bible that was faulty. Because I was reading it through the lens of my own fallible 21st century understanding and traditions instead of reading it through the tradition in which it was first written and understood.
The turning point for me came with the birth of Moriah. Even though I submitted to being married in Greg's Church, I drew the line at having our children baptized Catholic. My faith was equally as important to me, and I didn’t believe in infant baptism. When preparing for marriage, neither Greg nor his priest pressed the issue. Fr. Wood told me, “you don’t have to promise anything; you’re not the one who’s Catholic.”
My dear friend Andrea, who had also been raised Baptist, started attending a Presbyterian church and brought up the subject of infant baptism. I argued against it. And then my soul wouldn’t rest. I felt the unmistakable, persistent nudge to have Moriah baptized. I had to question what I believed about baptism and why, question what the Catholic Church teaches about baptism and why, search Scripture, search early Christian writings for what they understood about baptism and how they practiced baptism…yes, while praying to the Holy Spirit for guidance.
Once I made the decision to have Moriah baptized, I was pretty sure I would become Catholic as well. But all my research was done in secret. I didn't want Greg to suspect I was seeking, just in case I came across something that would cause me to change my mind.
One Sunday, while Greg was at the hospital working, I went to his Church after Mass, and Fr. Wilfred stayed and talked with me for about 3 hours. When Greg came home that evening, I announced to him, "I've talked to your priest about having Moriah baptized, and I've decided to become Catholic as well." I'll never forget the look on his face, the way his eyes filled with tears. It’s one of my cherished memories.
I began classes in fall of 2001 and was received into The Church that Jesus founded on Easter Vigil 2002. I am to this day filled with gratitude at being led home. My soul is home.
I began classes in fall of 2001 and was received into The Church that Jesus founded on Easter Vigil 2002. I am to this day filled with gratitude at being led home. My soul is home.
The nightmares stopped soon after Greg and I created our home together and I began the process of converting to the Catholic faith. I finally began healing from my rough start in life, a long, slow process. Over time, I began to understand more about why bad things happen to people who don’t deserve it and trust God to use those circumstances to bring about greater good, but I’ll save that deep conversation for another time.
God promises peace, and He keeps His promises. We just gotta trust Him enough to follow where He leads us.
I just briefly touched on topics here, I didn't get too deep or pull out all the Bible verses or references, because this is my story, and I wanted to keep it a short story, not a novel, not a documentary.
I hope to revisit some topics more in-depth later, and I'll bring the references then.


Comments
Post a Comment